Load Balancer Subsets

Envoy may be configured to divide hosts within an upstream cluster into subsets based on metadata attached to the hosts. Routes may then specify the metadata that a host must match in order to be selected by the load balancer, with the option of falling back to a predefined set of hosts, including any host.

Subsets use the load balancer policy specified by the cluster. The original destination policy may not be used with subsets because the upstream hosts are not known in advance. Subsets are compatible with zone aware routing, but be aware that the use of subsets may easily violate the minimum hosts condition described above.

If subsets are configured and a route specifies no metadata or no subset matching the metadata exists, the subset load balancer initiates its fallback policy. The default policy is NO_FALLBACK, in which case the request fails as if the cluster had no hosts. Conversely, the ANY_ENDPOINT fallback policy load balances across all hosts in the cluster, without regard to host metadata. Finally, the DEFAULT_SUBSET causes fallback to load balance among hosts that match a specific set of metadata. It is possible to override fallback policy for specific subset selector.

Subsets must be predefined to allow the subset load balancer to efficiently select the correct subset of hosts. Each definition is a set of keys, which translates to zero or more subsets. Conceptually, each host that has a metadata value for all of the keys in a definition is added to a subset specific to its key-value pairs. If no host has all the keys, no subsets result from the definition. Multiple definitions may be provided, and a single host may appear in multiple subsets if it matches multiple definitions.

During routing, the route’s metadata match configuration is used to find a specific subset. If there is a subset with the exact keys and values specified by the route, the subset is used for load balancing. Otherwise, the fallback policy is used. The cluster’s subset configuration must, therefore, contain a definition that has the same keys as a given route in order for subset load balancing to occur.

This feature can only be enabled using the V2 configuration API. Furthermore, host metadata is only supported when using the EDS discovery type for clusters. Host metadata for subset load balancing must be placed under the filter name "envoy.lb". Similarly, route metadata match criteria use the "envoy.lb" filter name. Host metadata may be hierarchical (e.g., the value for a top-level key may be a structured value or list), but the subset load balancer only compares top-level keys and values. Therefore when using structured values, a route’s match criteria will only match if an identical structured value appears in the host’s metadata.

Examples

We’ll use simple metadata where all values are strings. Assume the following hosts are defined and associated with a cluster:

Host

Metadata

host1

v: 1.0, stage: prod

host2

v: 1.0, stage: prod

host3

v: 1.1, stage: canary

host4

v: 1.2-pre, stage: dev

The cluster may enable subset load balancing like this:

---
name: cluster-name
type: EDS
eds_cluster_config:
  eds_config:
    path: '.../eds.conf'
connect_timeout:
  seconds: 10
lb_policy: LEAST_REQUEST
lb_subset_config:
  fallback_policy: DEFAULT_SUBSET
  default_subset:
    stage: prod
  subset_selectors:
  - keys:
    - v
    - stage
  - keys:
    - stage
    fallback_policy: NO_FALLBACK

The following table describes some routes and the result of their application to the cluster. Typically the match criteria would be used with routes matching specific aspects of the request, such as the path or header information.

Match Criteria

Balances Over

Reason

stage: canary

host3

Subset of hosts selected

v: 1.2-pre, stage: dev

host4

Subset of hosts selected

v: 1.0

host1, host2

Fallback: No subset selector for “v” alone

other: x

host1, host2

Fallback: No subset selector for “other”

(none)

host1, host2

Fallback: No subset requested

stage: test

empty cluster

As fallback policy is overriden per selector with “NO_FALLBACK” value

Metadata match criteria may also be specified on a route’s weighted clusters. Metadata match criteria from the selected weighted cluster are merged with and override the criteria from the route:

Route Match Criteria

Weighted Cluster Match Criteria

Final Match Criteria

stage: canary

stage: prod

stage: prod

v: 1.0

stage: prod

v: 1.0, stage: prod

v: 1.0, stage: prod

stage: canary

v: 1.0, stage: canary

v: 1.0, stage: prod

v: 1.1, stage: canary

v: 1.1, stage: canary

(none)

v: 1.0

v: 1.0

v: 1.0

(none)

v: 1.0

Example Host With Metadata

An EDS LbEndpoint with host metadata:

---
endpoint:
  address:
    socket_address:
      protocol: TCP
      address: 127.0.0.1
      port_value: 8888
metadata:
  filter_metadata:
    envoy.lb:
      version: '1.0'
      stage: 'prod'

Example Route With Metadata Criteria

An RDS Route with metadata match criteria:

---
match:
  prefix: /
route:
  cluster: cluster-name
  metadata_match:
    filter_metadata:
      envoy.lb:
        version: '1.0'
        stage: 'prod'